What is the restart when, on a penalty kick, an attacker encroaches and the goalkeeper saves the ball but it rebounds to the encroacher?

In the scenario presented, when an attacker encroaches during a penalty kick, the appropriate action is to retake the penalty kick. This is due to the fact that the Laws of the Game specify that if a player commits an infringement during the taking of a penalty, the kick is considered to be not valid. The encroachment disrupts the integrity of the penalty kick situation, and the law recognizes that the offense has occurred, necessitating a retake.

While it might seem logical to reward the defending team with a free kick due to the encroachment, the dynamic of the penalty kick means that the law specifically calls for a retake when the encroaches come into play before the kick is taken. The key detail here is that the act of the goalkeeper saving the shot does not negate the encroachment, and since the attacker who infringed upon the rules was the one who gained possession of the ball after the save, the kick must be taken again to ensure fairness.

Therefore, the correct answer reflects the appropriate application of the laws governing penalty kicks, emphasizing the enforcement of rules to maintain the fairness of the game.